Focus then shifted to cash in the context of crises, with Barbara Jaroszek (Narodowy Bank Polski) presenting Poland's extraordinary response to surging cash demand and recent logistical challenges. The daily value of cash withdrawals increased 17 times their usual level at the beginning of the war in Ukraine.
Marc Schwartz (Monnaie de Paris) detailed how ‘the new currency wars’ combine the historical country-driven challenge to dominate global currency reserve, with the emergence of private issuers of digital currencies and crypto assets. The competition is intensifying with the deterioration of the geopolitical context and the weakening of multilateral institutions.
Franz Seitz (Weiden Technical University of Applied Sciences) showed how the 4 A’s – access, availability, acceptance, and affordability – are a necessary condition to guarantee cash infrastructure resilience. The discussion however suggested that acting on the supply-side alone was not sufficient and a 5th A – Affection – should be added to the equation. Speaking on affordability, Malte Krüger (Hochschule Ashaffenburg) presented the latest Bundesbank study on the costs of cash and card payments from a consumer perspective. The innovation lies in the attempt to quantify non-monetary costs, typically time spent to withdraw cash as well as the cost of privacy or rather the cost of the loss of privacy when making a card transaction.
Felix Redondo (Banco de España) shared lessons from Spain's response to two recent crises; storm DANA, brought devastating flooding to Valencia, and a widespread power blackout Based on the analysis of four different types of shocks - health, geopolitical, infrastructure, sovereign debt - Alejandro Zamora-Pérez (ECB) showed that crises can lead to extreme surges in cash demand. He compared cash to the spare tyre of the payment system. In times of crisis, the resilience of cash supersedes the objective of efficiency.Antti Heinonen, external advisor to the Bank of Finland providing a global analysis of evolution of cash demand showed that banknotes volumes as opposed to value are the most relevant metric to monitor. However, the majority of central banks do not publish this data.
Several institutions presented innovative solutions to strengthen the resilience of the cash cycle. Roel van Anholt (DNB), explained that the bank has started processing safe-bags, to increase the capability to process retail deposits. More surprising, the bank will deploy ATMs on the remote Caribbean island of Saba and Statia which are underserved. Scott Forster (CPT Group) highlighted the fragility of the cash infrastructure as a result of high concentration and declining activity of the cash-in-transit industry. James Leroux (Pin4) showed how cash is uniquely important for vulnerable individuals; cardless cash disbursement platforms offer a tristed disbursement method in disaster situations. Stefan Wikman (Bancomat) and Mikael Schlaug (PA Consulting) explained how Swedish ATM utility re-insourced cash handling and logistics to strengthen the cash infrastructure. Graham Mott (Link) showed that in spite of growing cash in circulation in the UK, ATM transactions are continuing to decline albeit at a slower pace than anticipated prior Covid. Bank hubs are an alternative to ATMs and offer a broader range of cash services (bill payment; access to change, banking enquiries..). 86 hubs are live and the numbers are growing.